bkshopr_IHB
New member
The idea of every front door greet the street has fallen apart with this enclave.

Matchbox said:Plan 2 in defunct Andulusia. Plan 3 is similar to the 3 story plan 3 at Portisol.
irvine_home_owner said:So is Andalusia going to be Prado'ed off like in Portola Springs?
(I'm reminded of Lost every time I say Andalusia... I must be saying it wrong)
bkshopr said:I have been thinking a lot about stucco houses. Many plain stucco boxes are actually very nice. The honest and simplified facade like the missions is just lovely. It is just a 4 corner structure. Why do designers have to overkill a simple facade?
A stucco home without restraint with too many goops, bad proportion, too many plane breaks, complicated roofs, and too many corners is like turning the beautiful America Ferrera into Ugly Betty.
Matchbox said:irvine_home_owner said:So is Andalusia going to be Prado'ed off like in Portola Springs?
(I'm reminded of Lost every time I say Andalusia... I must be saying it wrong)
I'd guess most likely it's going to be Prado'ed; the thing is I've never seen the plan 2 Andalusia in any of the Cal Pac developments before. I think it was developed just for this neighborhood. Maybe someone else has seen it? It could be the one one of a kind house in all of Irvine outside of Shady Canyon that isn't flamboyant, gaudy, disproportional, or scary.
EvaLSeraphim said:Matchbox said:irvine_home_owner said:So is Andalusia going to be Prado'ed off like in Portola Springs?
(I'm reminded of Lost every time I say Andalusia... I must be saying it wrong)
I'd guess most likely it's going to be Prado'ed; the thing is I've never seen the plan 2 Andalusia in any of the Cal Pac developments before. I think it was developed just for this neighborhood. Maybe someone else has seen it? It could be the one one of a kind house in all of Irvine outside of Shady Canyon that isn't flamboyant, gaudy, disproportional, or scary.
I may be wrong, but I think Andalusia was identical or similar to the Campanile "in-fill" project in North Park Square. I say in-fill because it was a land sale option for TUSD that they let expire and the project was started well after the rest of NPS was built out.
Mcdonna1980 said:bkshopr said:I have been thinking a lot about stucco houses. Many plain stucco boxes are actually very nice. The honest and simplified facade like the missions is just lovely. It is just a 4 corner structure. Why do designers have to overkill a simple facade?
A stucco home without restraint with too many goops, bad proportion, too many plane breaks, complicated roofs, and too many corners is like turning the beautiful America Ferrera into Ugly Betty.
Well said. When I walk through Woodbury, I'm always struck by how many different windows sizes one house can have. I think Stonetree Manor could have been beautiful with a symmetrical design. Look at the all the window sizes on that one in the top left hand corner. It's just overkill.
![]()
Matchbox said:EvaLSeraphim said:Matchbox said:irvine_home_owner said:So is Andalusia going to be Prado'ed off like in Portola Springs?
(I'm reminded of Lost every time I say Andalusia... I must be saying it wrong)
I'd guess most likely it's going to be Prado'ed; the thing is I've never seen the plan 2 Andalusia in any of the Cal Pac developments before. I think it was developed just for this neighborhood. Maybe someone else has seen it? It could be the one one of a kind house in all of Irvine outside of Shady Canyon that isn't flamboyant, gaudy, disproportional, or scary.
I may be wrong, but I think Andalusia was identical or similar to the Campanile "in-fill" project in North Park Square. I say in-fill because it was a land sale option for TUSD that they let expire and the project was started well after the rest of NPS was built out.
Andulusia was integrated as part of the original Woodbury Masterplan for the SE neighborhood of single family homes. SW(Cypress Square) and SE (Arbor Garden) Woodbury was almost identical to the way it was laid out. (like a mirror image centered on Keystone. (Keystone is a community entry street in the middle of WB south side.) SW Woodbury consists of the single family detached neighborhoods of Mille Fleurs, Villa Rosa, and Portisol.
Most of Cal Pac's projects are very similar. I've seen many of theCampanile houses in other neighborhoods: NP, NWoodII, and QH. Plan 1 and plan 3 in Andalusia is nearly identical to the the plans at Portisol. (It would have been unfortunate, because the masterplan called for each sub-neighborhood to be unique.) I was only referring to the Plan 2 in Andalusia as one of a kind because I have never seen it before.
BK mentioned the Sienna homes in WE. Sienna was also a brand new product that never got launched beyond the model homes being built.
In Woodbury, only Montecito and Carmel would qualify in your description of an infill project. (though WB is yet to be built out) This was the site originally designated for a middle school.