iacrenter said:
If you love lobster rolls and are ever in NYC, try eating at the Pearl Oyster Bar in Greenwich Village. One of the best I've had.
I was just in NY a couple weeks back and had the lobster roll at Luke's Lobster (near wall street) and it was fantastic. Pricey, but fantastic. Best I ever had (but I am not a lobster roll connoisseur)....in fact, I think it is like the second I ever had. IIRC, mine did not have mayo, so I guess it was a connecticut one (but it wasn't overly buttery either...light and flavorful).