PatStar -
Yep I have done the research and do not think the IUSD schools are better at all. I am also a firm believer that scores are just scores and it really boils down to the teacher and the individual experience for each child. It is more the perception of other people. Again, not because I care about what people think, but more for resale. What you said resonated with me though about chosing what is right for our family now. I think sometimes I worry too much about making the "perfect choice". When there really is no perfect choice. We have said, when our house sells, we will look and buy what feels right at that time based on what is available.
I actually do not like the super competitive environment and this is a concern I have about IUSD. I want my kids to enjoy life and not just be all about books, etc. I feel my kids have way too much homework already and kind of feel bad for them. I guess when we actually have to buy, we will just buy what feels right.
Actually, the LA times just had a few part series that evaluated LAUSD schools and showed that some of the schools with the best ratings showed the worst improvement over time and sometimes had some really bad individual teachers. It was really interesting and just reinforces that everyone's experience is different. In fact, one of my favorite teachers that my son had was in 1st grade and it was a teacher that had the reputation at the school for being strict and not warm and fuzzy. She has been one of my favorite teachers so far and my experience with her was totally different than what everyone describes.
IHO - I agree with you, I like the open floor plans, but need more rooms!