I'm giving another vote of confidence to Wawanesa... prices lower than anyone out there except maybe Mercury (and only by a little), great customer service by web reputation and by personal experience, and easy online payments. Have used them for my four cars for about 10 years and they didn't even blink at insuring my Maserati (and at a super-low rate to boot). They paid for a claim I had years ago almost instantly and without any hassle. Also use them for homeowner's insurance, and they are one of the few companies that offer reasonably priced earthquake insurance in CA.