While I've been with AAA for 30+ years, they too are beginning to get pricey. As a new client you may have the same issue on costs, but give them a shot.
Professionally speaking, Aaron Rosen of Arc 23 Insurance (an insurance brokerage) is a well known provider and a trusted resource. Of the clients that have reached out to Aaron, each one has been well satisfied with their new policy or with the information Aaron has given them to find insurance in this market.